Yeah - I just cut gaskets out of high quality cork sheet - gas and oil.
But here's a tip: Spruce is now selling brand new Aeronca caps, both vented and non-vented, for just a few bucks more than NAPA. I got one of each just to make sure I don't run out! They look like the originals.
I find that the Cubs need that little "pffft" on top that looks like a pitot. The non-vented cap, some copper tube, and solder does that just fine. Saves sixty bucks.