fabricfan
FRIEND
Petersburg, Alaska
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, I guess they could have put him in prison forever with his keep paid for by the tax payers (per prisoner costs can easily run $70 per day)... from what I have read they took away to tools he used to willfully and repeatedly violate the law, which sounds appropriate to me.The seizing of personal property by the government is a problem that needs to be addressed. it goes too far.
The seizing of personal property by the government is a problem that needs to be addressed. it goes too far.
I think that the point that Brittle was trying to make is more about judicial activisim than anything else. There needs to be a limit to government confisication and asset forfeiture laws. Our government especially on the national level has become way too intrusive in our day to day lives. As a result many of us find ourselves intimidated by our government. The government has used asset forfeiture as a means to punish the guilty when they couldn't get convictions for all they "new" that had been done.
Kurt new the chances he was taking and has been taking for many years, he deserved what he got.
He stated that they should seize guns and bows, but not airplanes. You are comparing apples to oranges. Here is an instance where a guy finally got what he deserved and people are whining that the government shouldn't be doing it. This is the exact reason the law exists.This guy was busted for fishing and hunting (assuming guns and bows) so did they confiscate those items? They should have but not airplanes.
Brittle,
Again, it is NOT the courts that establish forfeiture of property as part of sentencing, it is the legislators and commissions who promulgate the statutes.
Most judges do NOT like to assign jail time for game law violations, for some reason. I suspect most judges don't view game violations as a violation against people, therefore not as "significant". So, it's often easier for a judge to forfeit the "tools" used to violate the statute than it is to assign jail time. In this guy's case, he got both, but jail time reduced.
Like another I can think of, this guy will probably be right back at it as soon as he's out of jail. No guide's license to lose now.....
MTV
With as much of an ass as this guy was, and as much bush as there is in alaska why didn't someone just go wack this guy already.
Stewart I wasn't suggesting that I would ever operate that way I'm a law abiding citizen. But when you start threatening people, lets just say you try that with the wrong person "and you know things happen". You and I might be law abiding but not everyone is.That's an awful comment to make about anyone.
You guys have turned this thread into a gang beating of an already established bad reputation. You all must feel really good about yourselves.
SB
We must not be talking about the same thing if you’re starting to infer I look stupid and wanting to come to my house and steal from me? I'm new here. This is not my website and I am just a member and visitor and while in someone else’s house I will treat all participates with respect. This is Steve’s website and can be shutdown anytime he wants to.
For clarity, please let me say it again...this guy deserves punishment. Throw him in prison for the rest of his life. (Curious why the judge suspended about a year of the sentence)
My comments are not about that he was rapping the land, making large sums of money and getting off easy. Quite the opposite.
I know he wasn’t a Joe 6-pack going fishing and getting busted, he was a professional guide.
Like I said too... the wildlife is very precious to the people of Alaska and depend on it.
So now we went from don't seize an aircraft to throw him in jail for the rest of his life? I'm already starting to like you more. And the judges typically suspend some jail time so they will have that hanging over their head for the next time they think about committing a crime. It does cost to keep people in jail and no matter how important wildlife is, crimes against humans usually gets more attention.For clarity, please let me say it again...this guy deserves punishment. Throw him in prison for the rest of his life. (Curious why the judge suspended about a year of the sentence)
Again, I hate to keep pointing this out but once again you don't know what you are talking about. He was NOT a professional guide. That's the wholeI know he wasn’t a Joe 6-pack going fishing and getting busted, he was a professional guide.
Brittle,
Again, it is NOT the courts that establish forfeiture of property as part of sentencing, it is the legislators and commissions who promulgate the statutes.
Most judges do NOT like to assign jail time for game law violations, for some reason. I suspect most judges don't view game violations as a violation against people, therefore not as "significant". So, it's often easier for a judge to forfeit the "tools" used to violate the statute than it is to assign jail time. In this guy's case, he got both, but jail time reduced.
Like another I can think of, this guy will probably be right back at it as soon as he's out of jail. No guide's license to lose now.....
MTV
Brittle
I agree with your basic premiss. Unfortunately you were COMPLETELY misunderstood. Hang in there.
Bill