I'm no expert, have a couple hundred hours in an M7-235 and got my float rating in a Maule (albeit in Florida) but here's my opinion:
The Maule is not a Cub and it's not a Skywagon. It's a capable airplane but, like lots of others it does have a useful load problem. They have been working on upping the gross to, I believe, 2800 but it won't be a retrofit and if you've ever been to the Maule factory and met the people you'll know not to hold your breath waiting for it to get completed - things move at their own pace down there in Georgia.
The one thing the Maule does have going for it is price, you can't beat it with a stick. For one thing, you can't buy a new Skywagon and have you looked at the prices of a Cubcrafter's lately? The Maule has it's own niche market that it fills quite well.
Speaking of Cubcrafters, we went to their open house a couple of years ago - they host a great get together and I'd highly recommend it to anyone looking for something to do on a Saturday in October. Anyway, as short as those little Sport Cubs were landing they got beat by the Oregon Aero guys in their PC12 (who were carrying their golf cart in back) But I've always been a big Cub fan and I like Maules and Skywagons and Pilatus' too.
What I don't like are a bunch of snobs who fly into a back country strip with their Alaskan Bushwheel equipped be all to end all and then get miffed when some clown shows up in an Ercoupe
Here are a couple of clips from the Cubcrafters meet. Of course these aren't "real world" - one skinny pilot before eating lunch, barely enough gas and a pretty good wind but they are entertaining none the less.
Cub short take off
Maule short landing
Either way you can see a couple of guys having a blast and for most of us it's not really about much more than that.

[/url]