
Originally Posted by
DENNY
….. When a slick works they do fine. When they don't the symptoms are intermittent (usually starting) and very hard to figure out that it is the mags. DENNY
I had this issue years ago with the purchased-new-at-engine-overhaul Slicks on my old C170.
Hard starting, then flat ass wouldn't start one day when I was out.
AOG overnight and finally got it running (barely) the next day--
but enough to get it home, 10 miles away.
I was sure it was the mags, pulled them off and had Paul Nyenhaus test them on his testing bench.
Nope, they met Slick specs.
Turned out to be the plugs, which had about 550 hours on them.
I didn't know enough then to actually test the resistance through the plugs with an ohmmeter, so don't know what the actual readings were,
but apparently it was too high for the slicks to work.
Now you can correctly say it was the plugs that were the problem,
but I'd had my previous Bendix mags fire plugs with probably 3 times the number of hours on them and work just fine.
(my IA finally made me replace those old plugs-- "look at them, they're just all worn out")
So as far as I'm concerned, Bendix mags just throw a hotter spark than Slicks.
Maybe not a reason to replace airworthy slicks, but if I was buying new (or at engine overhaul) I'd go Bendix every time.
Bookmarks