Repositionable wheel skis are a 20 Craig as you get straight ski performace with the ability to put the wheels down and go "off road"..... penetration wheel skis.. about a 6 for performance, but a 12 for being able to go from gravel/pavement (indoor hangar) to paradise over a straight ski.!
Id agree generally.
The one down side to both penetration skis and retractable skis is additional weight.....you're now carrying around not only the weight of the skis, which is often substantial, but also the weight of wheels, brakes, etc.
That said, retractable wheel skis are wonderful devices on many levels. Some are better than others, so one can't generalize totally by saying retractable a are ALWAYS better than penetration skis, but... My experience with penetration skis has been that they are a compromise, and don't perform as well as retractables, particularly in deep snow or crusty snow. But again, there are different skis and different snow conditions.
i see a lot of ski flying pictures on the web in snow conditions where one could operate on wheels....if that's the kind of snow you'll be operating, penetration skis will work just fine....as a sort of safety device in case the snow ends up being deeper than you thought. On the other hand, I know some folks who operate penetration skis in some pretty deep snow as well.
But, straight skis will almost always outperform ANY wheel-ski in deep snow or challenging conditions.
And, finally, ANY ski will get you good and stuck in some snow conditions/depths. And the bigger/heavier the plane, the more likely you are to get stuck, of course. I've been so stuck in a 185 on 3600 retractable wheel skis I thought I'd never get out of there. That is known as "operator error", though. In real deep snow, in my opinion, it's almost impossible to have skis that are too big (bottom area). And, penetration skis give up some bottom area for the wheel penetration.
Ive be never flown a set of the Los Fernandez wheel skis, but I do have substantial experience in lots of different snow conditions on the later Rosti Fernandez skis, and in my opinion, they are the best skis around....light, huge bottoms, and a great design.
Hangaring a straight ski plane is no big deal, but operating from most airports sure can be, not to mention trying to find gas. Unless you have a VERY ski friendly airport, like Fairbanks Intl. where they groom strip and taxiways, or you have your own strip you can groom, then some form of wheel ski is about mandatory.
MTV